Delegate Advises W.Va. Chamber To Accent Positive

Mannix Porterfield
The Register-Herald, Jan. 8, 2007

CHARLESTON — Delegate Richard Browning has some advice for the West Virginia Chamber of Commerce — drop the negative tune and begin singing from the song book of achievements.

Chamber President Steve Roberts hasn’t yet turned in a report he promised to back up his claims a negative climate has driven some businesses away, the Joint Commission on Economic Development learned Sunday. “I guess it’s easier to run an ad,” Sen. Robert Plymale, D-Wayne, told fellow panelists.

Plymale’s allusion was to a controversial ad the Chamber ran last fall, zeroing in on what it perceived as a biased judicial system that is weighted against the business community. That ad came under severe criticism by some commission members, and Roberts eventually appeared before it to defend the message, pledging to supply the panel with proof of how the judicial system needs some fine-tuning to make West Virginia more attractive.

“I think if we’re going to promote business in West Virginia, the state’s leading business promoter should talk about the good things, the good things the Legislature has done in the past six to eight years,” Browning, D-Wyoming, said after the brief interims meeting. “Talk about those improvements, rather than tell people before they even get here that we are a bad place to do business, which I disagree with.”

Browning said the commission received a report from the West Virginia Trial Lawyers Association, refuting Roberts’ claims about the judicial system.

In recent years, Browning told Roberts at the December meeting, the Legislature has revamped the judicial system with a number of reforms, made sweeping changes in medical malpractice and general insurance, and privatized workers’ compensation. “I don’t think we’re a bad place to do business,” he said after Sunday’s meeting.

“I think we’re a wonderful place to do business. Those are things we ought to be marketing, some of the achievements we have done. We ought to be singing from the same hymnal to make a positive change for West Virginia .”

The commission wants a host of studies undertaken this year during interims, among them a comprehensive energy policy and the prospects of stripping economic development from the West Virginia Parkways Authority. By a legislative act, the authority not only manages the Turnpike but engages in economic and tourism projects.

“The name of the authority itself suggests that they ought to be in economic development,” Browning said. “I’ve often wondered how extensively they do the research and so forth necessary to allow them to make those kinds of decisions. In Wyoming County , they’ve invested in a couple of things I think are hanging on by the skin of their teeth.”

Before the Legislature moves to separate the authority from economic ventures, Browning wants to see how investments have been done in the past. “And how we can make any changes, if needed, to make it so we get the biggest bang for the buck in the future,” he said.

The commission also suggested a study on expanding the authority’s showcase venture, Tamarack in Beckley , into the Eastern Panhandle, but at Plymale’s behest, it agreed not to limit such an idea to one region.

Tamarack came under fire in a report by the Legislative Auditor, which portrayed it as a losing enterprise that needs a $2 million-a-year infusion of concessions revenue to keep it going — money that could have been used for upkeep on the Princeton-to-Charleston toll road.